
Despite a Superior Court ruling that a mask requirement posed little threat to Connecticut students, lawyers behind an ongoing challenge of the state mandate argued against dismissal of their case in a motion filed Monday.
The lawsuit, filed by two Republican state representatives—Doug Dubitsky and Craig Fishbein—on behalf of a group of Connecticut parents, seeks to remove a requirement that students wear masks in schools to help contain the spread of the COVID-19 virus.
Monday’s motion comes on the heels of a major defeat for the plaintiffs in the case. Earlier this month, Judge Thomas G. Moukawsher denied their request for the court to step in and remedy what they argued was an imminent physical and emotional threat to school children.
Moukawsher found no such threat and in ruling against an emergency injunction, the judge put to rest the most pressing element of the case.
However, Dubitsky and Fishbein argue that their lawsuit should not be dismissed because the state Education Department lacked the authority to enact the mandate in the first place. The agency, empowered by a series of pandemic-related executive orders from Gov. Ned Lamont, skirted traditional regulatory oversight when it required masks in schools, they said.
“The Defendants can, under their view of their emergency powers, simply enact any regulation they choose,” the lawyers wrote.
“There is nothing to stop them from mandating tomorrow that all children wear pressurized space suits and breath bottled oxygen as a condition of receiving a public education in Connecticut,” they wrote.
The Education Department, represented by the state Attorney General’s Office, has been arguing since September that the case should be dismissed. Initial complaints about the agency’s emergency authority were addressed by executive orders from Lamont. Meanwhile, individual complaints about how the mask mandate has been enforced are better directed at local school districts, the state has claimed.
Moukawsher has not yet ruled on the new motion from Dubitsky and Fishbein, but in prior rulings he has stated the mandate contains adequate exemptions for students who have medical difficulties with the requirement.
The judge has also suggested that Supreme Court decisions have granted the Executive and Legislative Branches broad powers in responding to emergencies. The current pandemic crisis has already resulted in the deaths of nearly as many Americans as World War II, he wrote.
“Based on the evidence in this case, the Connecticut Department of Education has not exceeded this especially broad power. Nothing the Connecticut government has done about school mask wearing has been shown as irrational and dangerous rather than, like all human action, in some ways imperfect. Indeed, it aligns with ordinary expectations,” the judge wrote in a previous ruling.
The plaintiffs argue this power goes too far and at some point the public health guidelines enacted by the Executive Branch during the pandemic must be subject to the sort of public scrutiny required by the traditional legislative process.
“If left unchecked, there would be no effective legal barriers or constitutional constraints to the Defendants’ ability to change the [state education] mandates at will for every public school child in Connecticut without notice, consultation, public input, or judicial review,” they wrote.
The litigation continues to unfold as many school districts around the state have struggled to maintain in-person learning. Potential exposures to the virus have forced many teachers to quarantine, leading to staffing shortages which have required some schools to revert back to remote learning.
As he argued to preserve the mask requirement last month, Assistant Attorney General Darren Cunningham suggested that Connecticut schools would not be able to safely operate without the mandate.
Support authentic, locally owned and operated public service journalism!
“This drastic, immense request of the court would no doubt result in the closure of our public schools,” he said.
Although the Centers for Disease Control recommends masks be worn in schools, Connecticut is not the only place where the idea has met some resistance. Similar requirements have prompted lawsuits in other states and, according to ProPublica, 11 states do not require students to wear masks and have left the call up to local districts.
More COVID-19 Coverage

COVID Transmission Increases in CT
As of Friday afternoon, Connecticut’s test positivity rate was 13.71% and there were 323 residents hospitalized with the virus. On Thursday, the Department of Public Health reported that 158 of Connecticut’s 169 municipalities qualified for the state’s “red alert” distinction for COVID-19, which is triggered when a community records at least 15 daily cases per…
Keep reading
Connecticut At High, Medium Risk of COVID Transmission
Connecticut’s COVID-19 test positivity rating was 10.35% on Thursday and all eight Connecticut counties were in the medium yellow or high orange categories on the CDC’s community spread map. Those community maps, created by the CDC in February, are supposed to tell people to take preventative steps such as masking and testing. Hartford, Middlesex and…
Keep reading
Advocates Make 11th Hour Pitch For Compassionate Release
Hartford, CT — Advocates seeking compassionate release from prison during public health emergencies like COVID rallied at the state Capitol hours before they saw their legislation die without action in either chamber. At the rally on Wednesday, protestors and advocates were demanding action from legislators to pass a bill that addresses COVID in prisons. The…
Keep reading
Legislating During COVID-19
The legislative session ends in three days now, that’s shorter than the amount of time someone should quarantine under CDC standards if they have COVID-19, so how are lawmakers coping? Sen. Saud Anwar, D-South Windsor, started experiencing symptoms two weeks ago and tested positive for COVID-19. Luckily the session wasn’t scheduled until last Tuesday, but…
Keep reading
Study Shows Union Nursing Homes Had Lower Rates of COVID-19
A recent study published by Health Affairs found that unionized nursing homes had lower resident COVID-19 mortality rates. Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, nursing home residents have accounted for roughly one of every six COVID-19 deaths in the United States. Nursing homes have also been very dangerous places for workers, with more than…
Keep reading
Senator Murphy Tests Positive For COVID
U.S. Sen. Chris Murphy announced on Twitter that he tested positive for COVID-19. “FYI after feeling mild symptoms overnight, I tested positive for COVID this morning. We’ve done the contact tracing and let people know. It’s a bummer, but I’m sure if I wasn’t fully vaccinated I would be feeling a lot worse. So remember…
Keep reading
COVID Cases Tick Back Up
Most of Gov. Ned Lamont’s executive orders, which were extended to April 15 by the legislature, have now expired just as Connecticut’s test positivity rate for COVID-19 is creeping back up and students at UConn are being asked to mask up again, starting today. According to the Department of Public Health, Connecticut recorded 3,939 positive…
Keep reading
House Green Lights Extension of COVID-19 Laws
The House gave final passage Wednesday to a package of four concepts that had been executive orders and are now law. Previously, the concepts were executive orders to address the COVID-19 pandemic.
Keep reading
Tong Tests Positive For COVID-19
Attorney General William Tong has tested positive for COVID-19. He is experiencing mild symptoms and quarantining at home.
Keep reading
Lieutenant Gov. Tests Positive For COVID-19, Days After Gov
Lt. Gov. Susan Bysiewicz tested positive for the COVID-19 virus during a routine rapid test over the weekend, her chief staff said in a Monday morning statement. Bysiewicz’s results follow Gov. Ned Lamont, who tested positive late last week. “I have tested positive for COVID-19,” Bysiewicz wrote on Twitter. “Thanks to the vaccine and booster…
Keep reading
Lamont Tests Positive for COVID-19
Gov. Ned Lamont tested positive for COVID-19 Thursday. The results from two rapid tests were positive and he’s awaiting the results of a PCR test, according to this staff. The 68-year-old governor received his second booster exactly a week ago, but has made it through the first two years of the pandemic without contracting the…
Keep reading
New Initiative Allows Same Day COVID Testing And Treatment
Hundreds of pharmacies and federally qualified community health centers across Connecticut are now offering COVID testing and treatments to patients at the same time and place. According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, these test-to-treat sites provide antiviral medication to hundreds of locations across the U.S, who then distribute them to patients…
Keep reading
YNHH Top Doc Boosts 2nd Boosters
If you’re eligible to get a second Covid-19 booster shot, go get it. Especially if you’re over 50 and have an underlying medical condition like diabetes that puts you at “high risk” of contracting a severe case of COVID. Read more from the New Haven Independent.
Keep reading
Federal COVID Funds To Limit Tax Relief In An Election Year
Like all states, Connecticut accepted billions of dollars from the federal government for COVID-19 relief, but that money limits how much the state can now consider cutting taxes. It’s bubbling up as a point of contention as lawmakers race to adjust the two-year state budget, which is currently experiencing a record surplus. Connecticut is expected…
Keep reading
Auditors Find West Haven Misspent A Majority of COVID Funds
An independent audit, released by Gov. Ned Lamont’s administration late Friday, found that roughly 80% of West Haven’s spending of COVID relief funds should not have been allowed due to ineligible expenses or insufficient documentation. The audit of how West Haven spent its $1.15 million in federal pandemic funding was conducted by CohnReznick and came…
Keep reading