
(Updated) A Superior Court judge concluded Wednesday that Gov. Ned Lamont’s executive orders did not violate the constitutional rights of the owners of a small neighborhood bar in Milford that was forced to close in March.
Kristine Casey of Casey’s Irish Pub sued the state in June claiming the decisions the governor was making were unconstitutional because they forced her to temporarily close the pub, which has three employees and a maximum capacity for 59 people.
“The pub is not a tourist attraction, but a neighborhood bar frequented by a small nucleus of regular customers,” the original complaint states. An estimated 10% of the pub’s business is food and 90% is beer and other alcohol.
In the lawsuit, Casey argued that it was not possible to provide outdoor drinking and dining because of the physical location of the pub. The pub is at the end of a strip of stores, and right outside the door of the pub is a sidewalk abutting a parking lot where there are 3 or 4 striped parking spaces.
“Outdoor service is not a viable option physically because the tables would completely block the sidewalk and there would be no protection from cars approaching to park, and fiscally because not enough customers could be served,” the complaint states.
While it may be difficult to operate the business under current guidelines, the court didn’t believe the state violated the rights of the pub owners.
In her decision, Superior Court Judge Barbara Bellis concluded that the governor “had the authority to issue executive orders to protect the public health.”
The state admitted the pub owners were suffering “irreparable harm and that they lack an adequate remedy at law.” But the attorney general argued that public health was more important.
“Our constitution is unambiguous” Attorney General William Tong said. “The Governor has broad authority after the declaration of public health and civil preparedness emergencies to take affirmative steps to protect public health and to save lives. The Governor’s orders have been lawful and justified, and they have saved lives. These measures have not been without sacrifice, but nothing can be more important right now than keeping people safe.”
Attorneys for Casey’s Pub argued that the executive orders are unconstitutional because they give the governor power to legislate that he otherwise wouldn’t have under the state constitution.
But Bellis concluded that the General Assembly created a special committee with the ability to disapprove of the governor’s declarations and that committee of 10 voted not to overrule the extension of Lamont’s emergency powers.
Support authentic, locally owned and operated public service journalism!
“In making this decision, the court feels great sympathy for the economic plight of the plaintiffs and other similarly situated individuals,” Bellis wrote. “The COVID-19 pandemic has caused immense disruptions not only to our public health system, but also to the state’s economy as a whole. Nevertheless, in our constitutional system of governance, it is up to the legislatures, not courts, to decide on the wisdom and utility of legislation … Courts do not substitute their social and economic beliefs for the judgment of legislative bodies, who are elected to pass laws.”
Jonathan Klein, the attorney for the pub, says they plan to appeal the decision.
More COVID-19 Coverage

Ousted Public Health Commissioner Renée Coleman-Mitchell details her federal discrimination lawsuit
Former State Department of Public Health Commissioner Renée Coleman-Mitchell is on WNPR discussing her federal lawsuit against the state.
Keep reading
Connecticut To Get FEMA Funds for COVID Testing Sites
Connecticut will receive more than $2 million in federal emergency funding to pay for the operation of COVID-19 testing sites during a six-month period last year, the Federal Emergency Management Agency announced Monday. The roughly $2.15 million will come from FEMA’s public assistance grant program and will be used to reimburse state funds used to…
Keep reading
COVID Transmission Increases in CT
As of Friday afternoon, Connecticut’s test positivity rate was 13.71% and there were 323 residents hospitalized with the virus. On Thursday, the Department of Public Health reported that 158 of Connecticut’s 169 municipalities qualified for the state’s “red alert” distinction for COVID-19, which is triggered when a community records at least 15 daily cases per…
Keep reading
Connecticut At High, Medium Risk of COVID Transmission
Connecticut’s COVID-19 test positivity rating was 10.35% on Thursday and all eight Connecticut counties were in the medium yellow or high orange categories on the CDC’s community spread map. Those community maps, created by the CDC in February, are supposed to tell people to take preventative steps such as masking and testing. Hartford, Middlesex and…
Keep reading
Advocates Make 11th Hour Pitch For Compassionate Release
Hartford, CT — Advocates seeking compassionate release from prison during public health emergencies like COVID rallied at the state Capitol hours before they saw their legislation die without action in either chamber. At the rally on Wednesday, protestors and advocates were demanding action from legislators to pass a bill that addresses COVID in prisons. The…
Keep reading
Legislating During COVID-19
The legislative session ends in three days now, that’s shorter than the amount of time someone should quarantine under CDC standards if they have COVID-19, so how are lawmakers coping? Sen. Saud Anwar, D-South Windsor, started experiencing symptoms two weeks ago and tested positive for COVID-19. Luckily the session wasn’t scheduled until last Tuesday, but…
Keep reading
Study Shows Union Nursing Homes Had Lower Rates of COVID-19
A recent study published by Health Affairs found that unionized nursing homes had lower resident COVID-19 mortality rates. Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, nursing home residents have accounted for roughly one of every six COVID-19 deaths in the United States. Nursing homes have also been very dangerous places for workers, with more than…
Keep reading
Senator Murphy Tests Positive For COVID
U.S. Sen. Chris Murphy announced on Twitter that he tested positive for COVID-19. “FYI after feeling mild symptoms overnight, I tested positive for COVID this morning. We’ve done the contact tracing and let people know. It’s a bummer, but I’m sure if I wasn’t fully vaccinated I would be feeling a lot worse. So remember…
Keep reading
COVID Cases Tick Back Up
Most of Gov. Ned Lamont’s executive orders, which were extended to April 15 by the legislature, have now expired just as Connecticut’s test positivity rate for COVID-19 is creeping back up and students at UConn are being asked to mask up again, starting today. According to the Department of Public Health, Connecticut recorded 3,939 positive…
Keep reading
House Green Lights Extension of COVID-19 Laws
The House gave final passage Wednesday to a package of four concepts that had been executive orders and are now law. Previously, the concepts were executive orders to address the COVID-19 pandemic.
Keep reading
Tong Tests Positive For COVID-19
Attorney General William Tong has tested positive for COVID-19. He is experiencing mild symptoms and quarantining at home.
Keep reading
Lieutenant Gov. Tests Positive For COVID-19, Days After Gov
Lt. Gov. Susan Bysiewicz tested positive for the COVID-19 virus during a routine rapid test over the weekend, her chief staff said in a Monday morning statement. Bysiewicz’s results follow Gov. Ned Lamont, who tested positive late last week. “I have tested positive for COVID-19,” Bysiewicz wrote on Twitter. “Thanks to the vaccine and booster…
Keep reading
Lamont Tests Positive for COVID-19
Gov. Ned Lamont tested positive for COVID-19 Thursday. The results from two rapid tests were positive and he’s awaiting the results of a PCR test, according to this staff. The 68-year-old governor received his second booster exactly a week ago, but has made it through the first two years of the pandemic without contracting the…
Keep reading
New Initiative Allows Same Day COVID Testing And Treatment
Hundreds of pharmacies and federally qualified community health centers across Connecticut are now offering COVID testing and treatments to patients at the same time and place. According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, these test-to-treat sites provide antiviral medication to hundreds of locations across the U.S, who then distribute them to patients…
Keep reading
YNHH Top Doc Boosts 2nd Boosters
If you’re eligible to get a second Covid-19 booster shot, go get it. Especially if you’re over 50 and have an underlying medical condition like diabetes that puts you at “high risk” of contracting a severe case of COVID. Read more from the New Haven Independent.
Keep reading