When a government program is broken, most good people in government want to fix it. But what if fixing the program means that the same perennially cash-strapped government will lose money?
That’s the question lawmakers will have to ask themselves as they consider what to do about Connecticut’s bottle deposit law, which we now know is on the verge of collapse, thanks to a terrific report this week by WNPR’s Patrick Skahill.
Connecticut’s bottle bill — wrongly labeled, I think, because it’s no longer proposed legislation and is an actual law — has been around since 1978, when members of the General Assembly were appalled at the state’s litter problem and wanted to do something positive for the environment.
After all, as the state Department of Energy and Environmental Protection says, states that have bottle deposit laws have higher rates of overall recycling than those without bottle laws. And it stands to reason that they have less litter involving soda-pop, water, and beer containers. But the deposit has remained at 5 cents since the legislation took effect on Jan. 1, 1980.
Do you take your redeemables back to the store or to a redemption center to claim your deposit? I did 20, 25 years ago. But a nickel was worth more back then and I had less disposable income. Now it’s 2017 and I can’t remember the last time I claimed a deposit. And no, it’s not just because 5 cents isn’t worth worrying about. Consider what you have to endure to return the returnables.
Rows of shoppers feed bottles into noisy machines that crunch the containers into smaller sizes. The machines sometimes break down and they must be must be emptied several times a day. In either case, customers often have to wait until the problem is taken care of. The air in the returnables room is a cross between stale beer and flat Mountain Dew. Who knows what kinds of critters lurk behind the machines — or in them?
That’s not to say I throw the beer bottles and soda cans away. I take them to my town transfer station, where they go into the single-stream recycling Dumpster along with cardboard, office paper, and the like. Sometimes there is a old man there picking the returnables out for redemption. So I lose a few dollars but the material is still recycled — occasionally it’s even returned — and I don’t have to suffer the indignity of standing in line in a nauseous place.
The economics don’t make sense for the businesses, either. The retailer pays the deposit up front when s/he buys from the distributor. The store or redemption center gives a nickel back to the consumer for every bottle or can returned. The distributor or manufacturer then reimburses the retailer for the deposit and adds a handling fee of anywhere between one-and-a-half cents and two cents per bottle or can, depending on the type of beverage that formerly filled the container.
Nearby states such and New York, Vermont, and Maine have handling fees between two and three times ours. Connecticut retailers and redemption centers say the handling fee might have been reasonable almost 30 years ago when the law was conceived.
Meanwhile, costs have risen for everything from utilities, to rent and insurance. Oh, and there is that little matter of the minimum wage, which rose to $10.10 per hour on new year’s day. Now there is pressure from Democratic lawmakers to increase it to $15 by 2022 — pressure Gov. Malloy seems to be resisting.
The big question, of course, is what happens to that nickel in the case of folks like yours truly — people who simply throw the bottles and cans into the garbage or lump them in with the curbside recycling without compunction or regret.
Well, until 2009 distributors and wholesalers got to keep the nickel to help them offset the costs of complying with the bottle law. Then the legislature decided the money was too great to resist and the law was changed so that unclaimed deposits went straight back to the state’s general fund.
So, how much money are we talking about here? For fiscal year 2016, the Department of Revenue Services reported $33 million in unclaimed deposits. In addition, quarterly redemption rates are trending down to 49 percent in the most recent four-quarter average. In other words, the lower the redemption rates, the more money the state makes. How perverse. Surely, that can’t be why the law was enacted in the first place.
Enter state Reps. Mary Mushinsky and Joe Gresko, who have proposed legislation to give at least some of the millions in unclaimed deposits back to the distributors.
This will be an interesting dance for lawmakers in Hartford. They absolutely hate to part with revenue — especially with a projected $1.4 billion deficit staring them in the face for the coming year. But if the private bottle and can redemption system collapses, what would happen? Would we abandon the program? Would the state simply take over the returnables business and set up its own redemption centers akin to those old auto emissions testing stations of yore? Would we establish a Connecticut Recycling and Redemption Authority?
Support authentic, locally owned and operated public service journalism!
That would surely be more expensive than sharing revenues with the distributors. Expect Mushinsky’s and Gresko’s bill to pass in some form. The state isn’t any good at running things like a business. Anyone remember the other CRRA?
Contributing op-ed columnist Terry Cowgill lives in Lakeville, blogs at ctdevilsadvocate.com and is news editor of The Berkshire Record in Great Barrington, Mass. Follow him on Twitter @terrycowgill.
DISCLAIMER: The views, opinions, positions, or strategies expressed by the author are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, or positions of CTNewsJunkie.com.
More State Budget news

Stefanowski Talks Abortion, Employee Raises & Budget In First Press Conference
For a half-hour Wednesday, Bob Stefanowski stood outside the state Capitol and fielded questions on abortion rights and state employee raises in a sign the Republican candidate plans to run a more conventional campaign in this year’s rematch with Gov. Ned Lamont.
Keep reading
Lamont Signs The Budget
Alongside Democratic legislative leaders, Gov. Ned Lamont signed the $24 billion budget adjustment Monday that includes $600 million in tax relief. That’s more than they anticipated they would be able to offer Connecticut residents this Election year because revenue came in higher than expected, but it still creates about an $800 million deficit in 2024. …
Keep reading
ANALYSIS | It’s A Wrap: The Winners and Losers of the 2022 Session
It was a short legislative session, but the House and the Senate were able to move a lot of business this year, including the passage of a $24-billion budget with around $600 million in tax cuts.
Keep reading
Connecticut Acts To Help Its Lead-Poisoned Children
After decades of inertia, Connecticut is finally moving to help its thousands of lead-poisoned children and prevent thousands of other young children from being damaged by the widespread neurotoxin.
Keep reading
Bill Bolstering Contracting Oversight Board In Jeopardy After Lamont Administration Raises Concerns
It passed unanimously in the Senate, but a bill that would give the State Contracting Standards Board greater oversight over state contracting appeared stalled in the House Wednesday on the last day of session. “The governor and I have not talked about the bill,” House Speaker Matt Ritter said. “The commissioners have sent us a…
Keep reading
Senate Approves Tax Cuts, Sends $24B Budget to the Governor
The state Senate gave final approval late Tuesday to a $24 billion election year budget plan that includes around $600 million in tax relief while enabling the state to make an $3.5 billion payment on its unfunded pension debt. Senators voted 24-12 at around 10:30 p.m. to send the midterm budget adjustment to the desk…
Keep reading
House Green-Lights $24B Budget
On a party-line vote early Tuesday, the House passed a $24 billion budget adjustment package containing more than $600 million in tax cuts which Democrats heralded as “historic” and Republicans derided as temporary. Lawmakers voted 95 – 52 at around 12:20 a.m. to send the 673-page budget document to the Senate for consideration before the…
Keep reading
Budget Materials
The General Assembly is preparing to debate adjustments to the $24 billion state budget. Below are a few of the documents we’ve been provided as back-up materials. The budget, HB 5506. Town runs. Car tax impact on municipalities. Finance Committee Power Point.
Keep reading
Lawmakers May Vote for First Pay Increase in 20 Years
With legislative retirements mounting, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle were considering Monday raising the salaries of General Assembly members for the first time in more than two decades and indexing their pay in the future. During a morning press briefing, House Speaker Matt Ritter told reporters that funding for pay raises had been…
Keep reading
Amid Surging Revenue, House Prepares to Vote on Budget Adjustments
Connecticut’s House of Representatives was expected to vote Monday on a $24 billion budget adjustment package, buoyed by revised revenue predictions that exceeded expectations by more than $350 million. The revised consensus figures released Monday confirm the surge in revenues that enabled Gov. Ned Lamont and legislative Democrats to reach an agreement last week on…
Keep reading
Dems Detail Budget Deal With $500 Mil in Tax Cuts, Extension of Gas Tax Holiday
Legislative Democrats and Gov. Ned Lamont’s administration announced Wednesday the details of a $24.2 billion budget adjustment package, which they say provides around $500 million in tax relief including extending a gas tax holiday until December. Lamont and legislative leaders outlined the agreement during an afternoon press conference in the state Capitol building. Both chambers…
Keep reading
Health Care Workers Call for New Hires
After a record number of health care workers are expected to retire this year, health care staff called on Gov. Ned Lamont to commit to filling 1,000 vacant positions by August 1 of this year. A record 1,137 state workers who notified the state that they will retire this year comes at a moment of…
Keep reading
Senate Joins House And Votes To Give Raises, Bonuses To State Employees
The Senate gave final approval by a 22-13 vote on a plan to give unionized state workers a set of raises and bonuses. The plan, negotiated by Gov. Ned Lamont’s administration and a coalition of public sector labor unions, provides three years of 2.5% raises and step increases as well as a total of $3,500…
Keep reading
House Advances Labor Deal In Historic Vote
Lawmakers in Connecticut’s House of Representatives signed off on a plan to give state workers a set of raises and bonuses Thursday in a mostly partisan vote on a negotiated labor agreement. The House voted 96 to 52 in support of the deal with 1 Republican, Rep. Tom Delnicki of South Windsor, joining all Democrats…
Keep reading
Republicans Propose Last-Minute Tax Package
Legislative Republicans pitched a $1.2 billion tax relief plan Thursday which reduces state income, sales and gas taxes and proposes to join other states in suing the federal government to challenge restrictions on spending pandemic relief funds. House and Senate Republicans announced the plan during a state Capitol press conference Thursday morning. It cuts the…
Keep reading
The Budget Battle Begins To Take Shape
Tax collections have improved and pushed Connecticut’s budget surplus to $4 billion, but the state budget still relies heavily on federal funding and without it the state would end up running a “sizeable operating deficit.” The Office of Policy and Management told state Comptroller Natalie Braswell Wednesday that if not for the use of the…
Keep reading