
The Attorney General’s office will try Monday to get a trial court judge to waive further action on a Supreme Court decision that found that all children are entitled to a quality, adequate education and the state should pay for it.
The Connecticut Coalition for Justice in Education Funding sued the state in 2005, alleging that under the state Constitution students are entitled to a public education that works, and one that assures them, at minimum, an adequate education. The Connecticut Supreme Court agreed in a 4-3 decision in 2010 and sent the case back to the trial court. Motions have been filed back and forth for the past three years in anticipation of a 2014 trial.
The Attorney General’s office, which is representing the state, argues that the complaint must be based on “the educational model existing at the time of the trial,” and the 2012 education reforms and 2013 changes to the Education Cost Sharing formula approved by the legislature satisfy the Supreme Court’s decision in the case.
But the coalition of school districts and the head of the state’s largest municipal lobby disagree.
“The 2012 and 2013 legislative actions lack sufficient basis in sound education research, and the ECS formula changes were fiscally driven rather than tied to the actual cost of providing a suitable education for all children,” Dianne Kaplan deVries, executive director of the Connecticut Coalition for Justice in Education Funding, said.
She said the funding levels remain “constitutionally insufficient.”
In court documents, Brian Mahoney, the chief financial officer at the state Education Department, said the legislature increased the Education Cost Sharing grant by $51.46 million in 2014 and $41.26 million in 2015. The boost in funding went to 119 towns and about 95 percent of it was directed at 30 of the lowest performing districts, called Alliance Districts, according to Mahoney.
But Jim Finley, CEO of the Connecticut Conference of Municipalities, said the increase in funding still doesn’t fully fund the formula.
“The ECS formula is intended to ‘equalize’ the ability of towns to pay for public schools at a level that ensures all students equal opportunities for educational excellence,” Finley said. “Since its inception, however, the ECS formula has never been fully funded.”
If it were fully funded it would total $2.7 billion, according to Finley.
“The actual 2012 grant was $1.89 billion, more than $763 million short of the ECS promise under the last formula which was revamped in 2007. The total ECS formula for 2013 was $1.94 billion and will be $1.99 billion in 2014 and $2.03 billion in 2015,” Finley testified in an affidavit.
The increased appropriation levels “are too small to significantly affect adequacy or equity in Connecticut,” Finley concluded.
The state argues that the plaintiffs say their complaint is about seeking educational equity, when it seems to the state that “the case is really about — and only about — obtaining significantly more state funding without any regard to other measures that are being or could be implemented to improve education.”
It says the coalition of school districts is asking the court to assume “that public education is constitutionally inadequate and will be at the time of trial, and that the only way to both determine and remedy this inadequacy is by counting the amount of money the state spends on education.”
The state argues in its briefs to the court that even facing large deficits, the state legislature and Gov. Dannel P. Malloy sought to make education a priority.
“Despite the projected deficit in Connecticut for the current fiscal year, the elected branches of government have chosen to make education a priority and have targeted money and reforms toward the lowest performing schools,” the state wrote in its motion to dismiss.
Malloy was one of the first plaintiffs to join the lawsuit when he was mayor of Stamford. Advocates were hopeful that he would settle the case before it went to trial as he transitioned into the governor’s office. He didn’t. However, a spokesman said Friday that just because the state hasn’t settled the case doesn’t mean the governor hasn’t done anything to advance the education system and increase funding every year.
“Between changes made to ECS formula and the money going to struggling school districts — both because of the education reform session and the new funding in the last session — we’re making progress in addressing this issue,” Andrew Doba, a spokesman for Malloy, said Friday.
But it’s comments like these that leave the plaintiffs scratching their heads.
“Why is the state wasting precious resources by raising such motions instead of seeking to work with CCJEF to devise a suitable funding system that supports the success of all children and their schools?” Herb Rosenthal, president of the coalition’s board, said Thursday.
The state’s Attorney General’s office declined comment in advance of Monday’s hearing, but it is expected to argue in a second motion to limit the scope of the case based on Supreme Court Justice Richard Palmer’s decision.
In his concurring opinion on the case in 2010, Palmer wrote that he believes “that the executive and legislative branches are entitled to considerable deference with respect to the determination of what it means, in practice, to provide for a minimally adequate, free public education.”
Support authentic, locally owned and operated public service journalism!
In other words, a separation of powers argument could be raised if the courts force the state legislature to spend money it may not have in order to achieve what the courts believe is a constitutional right. The plaintiff’s believe that Palmer’s opinion “might be viewed as more judicially conservative and more deferential to the legislature.”
Judge Kevin Dubay will hear oral argument on the two motions at 11 a.m. Monday in Hartford Superior Court. The case is currently scheduled to go to trial in July 2014.
Click here to read more about the 2010 decision overturning the 2007 decision in the case.
More State Budget news

Stefanowski Talks Abortion, Employee Raises & Budget In First Press Conference
For a half-hour Wednesday, Bob Stefanowski stood outside the state Capitol and fielded questions on abortion rights and state employee raises in a sign the Republican candidate plans to run a more conventional campaign in this year’s rematch with Gov. Ned Lamont.
Keep reading
Lamont Signs The Budget
Alongside Democratic legislative leaders, Gov. Ned Lamont signed the $24 billion budget adjustment Monday that includes $600 million in tax relief. That’s more than they anticipated they would be able to offer Connecticut residents this Election year because revenue came in higher than expected, but it still creates about an $800 million deficit in 2024. …
Keep reading
ANALYSIS | It’s A Wrap: The Winners and Losers of the 2022 Session
It was a short legislative session, but the House and the Senate were able to move a lot of business this year, including the passage of a $24-billion budget with around $600 million in tax cuts.
Keep reading
Connecticut Acts To Help Its Lead-Poisoned Children
After decades of inertia, Connecticut is finally moving to help its thousands of lead-poisoned children and prevent thousands of other young children from being damaged by the widespread neurotoxin.
Keep reading
Bill Bolstering Contracting Oversight Board In Jeopardy After Lamont Administration Raises Concerns
It passed unanimously in the Senate, but a bill that would give the State Contracting Standards Board greater oversight over state contracting appeared stalled in the House Wednesday on the last day of session. “The governor and I have not talked about the bill,” House Speaker Matt Ritter said. “The commissioners have sent us a…
Keep reading
Senate Approves Tax Cuts, Sends $24B Budget to the Governor
The state Senate gave final approval late Tuesday to a $24 billion election year budget plan that includes around $600 million in tax relief while enabling the state to make an $3.5 billion payment on its unfunded pension debt. Senators voted 24-12 at around 10:30 p.m. to send the midterm budget adjustment to the desk…
Keep reading
House Green-Lights $24B Budget
On a party-line vote early Tuesday, the House passed a $24 billion budget adjustment package containing more than $600 million in tax cuts which Democrats heralded as “historic” and Republicans derided as temporary. Lawmakers voted 95 – 52 at around 12:20 a.m. to send the 673-page budget document to the Senate for consideration before the…
Keep reading
Budget Materials
The General Assembly is preparing to debate adjustments to the $24 billion state budget. Below are a few of the documents we’ve been provided as back-up materials. The budget, HB 5506. Town runs. Car tax impact on municipalities. Finance Committee Power Point.
Keep reading
Lawmakers May Vote for First Pay Increase in 20 Years
With legislative retirements mounting, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle were considering Monday raising the salaries of General Assembly members for the first time in more than two decades and indexing their pay in the future. During a morning press briefing, House Speaker Matt Ritter told reporters that funding for pay raises had been…
Keep reading
Amid Surging Revenue, House Prepares to Vote on Budget Adjustments
Connecticut’s House of Representatives was expected to vote Monday on a $24 billion budget adjustment package, buoyed by revised revenue predictions that exceeded expectations by more than $350 million. The revised consensus figures released Monday confirm the surge in revenues that enabled Gov. Ned Lamont and legislative Democrats to reach an agreement last week on…
Keep reading
Dems Detail Budget Deal With $500 Mil in Tax Cuts, Extension of Gas Tax Holiday
Legislative Democrats and Gov. Ned Lamont’s administration announced Wednesday the details of a $24.2 billion budget adjustment package, which they say provides around $500 million in tax relief including extending a gas tax holiday until December. Lamont and legislative leaders outlined the agreement during an afternoon press conference in the state Capitol building. Both chambers…
Keep reading
Health Care Workers Call for New Hires
After a record number of health care workers are expected to retire this year, health care staff called on Gov. Ned Lamont to commit to filling 1,000 vacant positions by August 1 of this year. A record 1,137 state workers who notified the state that they will retire this year comes at a moment of…
Keep reading
Senate Joins House And Votes To Give Raises, Bonuses To State Employees
The Senate gave final approval by a 22-13 vote on a plan to give unionized state workers a set of raises and bonuses. The plan, negotiated by Gov. Ned Lamont’s administration and a coalition of public sector labor unions, provides three years of 2.5% raises and step increases as well as a total of $3,500…
Keep reading
House Advances Labor Deal In Historic Vote
Lawmakers in Connecticut’s House of Representatives signed off on a plan to give state workers a set of raises and bonuses Thursday in a mostly partisan vote on a negotiated labor agreement. The House voted 96 to 52 in support of the deal with 1 Republican, Rep. Tom Delnicki of South Windsor, joining all Democrats…
Keep reading
Republicans Propose Last-Minute Tax Package
Legislative Republicans pitched a $1.2 billion tax relief plan Thursday which reduces state income, sales and gas taxes and proposes to join other states in suing the federal government to challenge restrictions on spending pandemic relief funds. House and Senate Republicans announced the plan during a state Capitol press conference Thursday morning. It cuts the…
Keep reading
The Budget Battle Begins To Take Shape
Tax collections have improved and pushed Connecticut’s budget surplus to $4 billion, but the state budget still relies heavily on federal funding and without it the state would end up running a “sizeable operating deficit.” The Office of Policy and Management told state Comptroller Natalie Braswell Wednesday that if not for the use of the…
Keep reading