
Lawyers suing the governor over two executive orders they consider “unconstitutional” argued Thursday that the passage of legislation codifying the orders did not render their complaints moot.
The lawsuits center on two executive orders Gov. Dannel P. Malloy issued creating a pathway for home and daycare workers to unionize. In their complaints, attorneys Joe Summa and Deborah Stevenson, allege Malloy violated labor relations laws and the state constitution when he signed the executive orders.
But in May the legislature passed a bill giving the groups the right to collectively bargain and soon after the state filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuits in Superior Court. Judge James Graham heard arguments from both sides Thursday in Hartford.
The state’s motion, argued by Assistant Attorney General Robert Deichert, rests largely on the passage of the bill, which superseded the executive orders.
“Several people, including the plaintiffs advised the legislature of their concerns about the bill, and they disagreed,” Deichert said.
At times Graham seemed inclined to agree. He questioned Stevenson on whether the passage of the bill addressed her allegations that Malloy had violated the separation of powers doctrine.
“Doesn’t the action by the legislature cure any violations of separation of powers?” he asked.
Stevenson said it did not because both the day and home care providers held union elections before the General Assembly approved the bill, acting on the executive orders she contends Malloy had no authority to issue.
“It’s repugnant to the constitution. No amount of the legislature putting its stamp of approval on it will have any effect,” she said.
Still, Graham commented that neither Stevenson nor Summa addressed the passage of the bill in their lawsuits. While both said they intend to amend their complaints, the judge seemed reluctant to hear arguments attacking the new law when it wasn’t included in either attorneys’ briefs.
“We intend to stop the impact of the law,” Summa said at one point.
“The court doesn’t measure your intent. The court measures your legal tools,” Graham answered.
For his part, Summa largely avoided constitutional questions, instead relying on his experience as a labor attorney to argue against what he called an “immoral and illegal scheme.”
Summa pointed to Cathy Ludlum, a Manchester resident with spinal muscular atrophy who employs personal care attendants, saying the presence of a union interferes with her relationship with her team of employees.
“The state has basically put an 800 pound gorilla in the room with the disabled community,” he said of the union.
Summa also argued that the executive orders were framed as information gathering tools, and said workers who voted to unionize may not have realized they were selecting a union.
But with the orders now being supplanted by the legislation, Graham questioned whether Summa was really just attacking the legislation. He asked Summa whether he thought the legislature was barred from adopting ideas generated by the working groups established by the governor’s executive orders.
“Where do I draw the line?” the judge asked. “Where do I circumscribe the legislative powers under the constitution because the plaintiffs don’t like an action of the executive?”
Though Deichert said that the legislation was not intended to allow the workers to collectively bargain benefits that would result in reduced services for people like Ludlum, Summa alleged it could happen. And if it did she would likely lose the ability to live on her own and would be forced to move to a nursing home, he said.
“Don’t tell me there’s no standing, it’s affecting peoples’ lives,” he said.
After the hearing, Andrew McDonald, Malloy’s chief legal counsel, said Summa and Stevenson were making political arguments for the Tea Party and the Yankee Institute, a conservative think tank helping to fund the litigation. He said he was accustomed to dealing with the “radical Right” in the political arena, but this was something new.
“This was the first time in 20 years of practicing law I’ve watched the radical Right in the courtroom. It was a surreal and bizarre experience,” he said.
Support authentic, locally owned and operated public service journalism!
However, Sen. Joseph Markley, a plaintiff to the complaints, said he felt they made valid legal arguments. Rep. Rob Sampson, who’s also a plaintiff, agreed, saying the fact the union elections were held before the passage of the bill makes them illegal.
“You can’t make scrambled eggs until the chicken lays the eggs,” he said.
With the arguments made, Graham will decide whether to grant the state’s motion to dismiss the complaints or allow the lawsuits to proceed in court. He did not set a timeline for the decision Thursday.
More Health Care News & Analysis

6 Common Barriers Men Face When Seeking Mental Health Support
The outward effects of mental illness can often be dismissed as a sign of weakness or personal failure. For men, this type of social stereotyping can be especially hard to escape — being told to “man up” is a common refrain that can be reductive and stigmatizing.
Keep readingMedical Examining Board Fines Doctor $10,000
The state Medical Examining Board on Tuesday fined an Oxford doctor $10,000 for fraudulently using another doctor’s name and Drug Enforcement Agency registration number to prescribe controlled substances to a family member.
Keep reading
Clinical Trials With Immunotherapy Drugs Are Source Of Hope And Challenges In Treating Aggressive Breast Cancer
Joshalyn Mills of Branford and Nancy Witz of Kensington had the best possible results after being treated in clinical trials with immunotherapy drugs for aggressive breast cancer: Their tumors were eliminated. But while there are dramatic successes with immunotherapy drugs, there are also many failures, and researchers are trying to find out why in hopes…
Keep reading
Coalition of Health Insurers Questions Viability of Connecticut Partnership Plan
Members of Connecticut’s Health Care Future, a coalition of health insurers, hospitals, and businesses, are questioning whether Connecticut lawmakers have done enough this year to protect teachers and municipal employees from increases in health insurance premiums. “Despite repeated bailouts from taxpayers, the Connecticut Partnership Plan continues to be a fiscal Titanic that demonstrates why government-controlled health…
Keep reading
AG’s Tackle Mental Health Parity
Attorneys General in Connecticut and Rhode Island threw their support Monday behind a coalition of mental health advocacy groups asking a federal appeals court to revisit a recent ruling giving insurance companies more flexibility to deny mental health claims.
Keep reading
Budget Green Lights Psychedelic Therapies
Buried in the budget Gov. Ned Lamont signed this week is a provision that would create a pilot program to allow Connecticut to be the first-in-the-nation to study the impact of psychedelic drugs like psilocybin and MDMA on patients with depression and PTSD. The budget now creates a pilot program within the Department of Mental…
Keep readingMore Labor News

Lamont Inks New Employment Law Backed By Unions
In a victory for state labor unions, Gov. Ned Lamont ignored a lobbying effort by business organizations and signed a bill Tuesday prohibiting employers from holding “captive audience” meetings to potentially discourage workers from unionizing.
Keep reading
States With The Largest Unionized Workforces
Where does Connecticut stand in the list of states with the most unionized employees?
Keep reading
Business Leaders Make Push To Veto Captive Audience Bill
Connecticut business leaders are leaning on Gov. Ned Lamont to veto a bill that would restrict what employers can say in the workplace. The bill, which has been a priority of labor unions for years, is being described by business owners as an unconstitutional attempt to restrict workplace communications and an infringement on employer free…
Keep reading
ANALYSIS | It’s A Wrap: The Winners and Losers of the 2022 Session
It was a short legislative session, but the House and the Senate were able to move a lot of business this year, including the passage of a $24-billion budget with around $600 million in tax cuts.
Keep reading
‘Captive Audience’ Bill Headed To Governor’s Desk
Legislation prohibiting Connecticut employers from holding “captive audience” meetings to discourage workers from organizing received final approval in the House late Friday despite Republican arguments it was preempted by federal law. The bill passed in a 88 to 56 vote, generally along party lines. Eight Democrats joined all but one Republican in voting against it.…
Keep reading
Health Care Workers Call for New Hires
After a record number of health care workers are expected to retire this year, health care staff called on Gov. Ned Lamont to commit to filling 1,000 vacant positions by August 1 of this year. A record 1,137 state workers who notified the state that they will retire this year comes at a moment of…
Keep reading